C is for Critique Group

Callaway Critique members

My Critique partners

This letter of the A-Z Challenge was easy. I wouldn’t be writing today if I didn’t belong to the Callaway Critique Group.

Most successful writers recommend a good critique group and the web is full of advice on how to form, find, or manage one.  There are debates on whether it is better to meet in person or online, whether meetings should be structured or laid back, and even instructions on how to interview “applicants.”  The general consensus seems to be that good critique groups don’t just happen – they must be planned.

I didn’t actually read any of this advice before we started the group. That’s a good thing, because it probably would have scared me off of the whole idea.   Our critique group sprang from a larger writer’s group that had been meeting once a month  for several years.    The large group was all about projects:  readings, anthologies, workshops for beginners, and  even a mentoring program for teen writers.

Some of us wanted to spend more time critiquing and getting critiques for our own writing.  It felt selfish at the time, but splitting away from the big group is the best thing I ever did for my writing.

Most expert say a critique group should be small, no more that five or six members. We have a core group of five.   We are all novelists, but genres and styles vary:  literary, mystery, romance, science fiction, fantasy, horror.  (Yes, I know that’s more than five.) And if someone brings in a memoir or a bit of freelance copy-writing, nobody complains. We critique it.

We’ve been getting together for breakfast every other Saturday for about seven years.  We share manuscripts by email a few days before each meeting. We also have an online group that allows us to keep in touch at a moments notice.  Some days the emails fly back and forth, other days it’s quiet. But we always know the others are there if we need a query letter proof read right away, or quick sympathy and support after getting an impersonal rejection.

Bottom line, if you’re a new writer and don’t belong to a critique group, find one or form your own. It’s worth the effort.


Enhanced by Zemanta
This entry was posted in A to Z April Challenge, Memoir, Writing & Writers and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to C is for Critique Group

  1. I’ll be happy when my life returns to some sort of normal schedule so I have time for my crit group again. I miss them!

  2. Carolyn Paul Branch says:

    Sometimes life interferes, doesn’t it? Make time as soon as you can. Thanks for stopping by!

  3. tara tyler says:

    sounds perfect to me! you have to do whats best for you! i found crit partners on line, but an in person group would be lovely! dont know how much critting i would do, tho. i like to chat =)

    • Carolyn Paul Branch says:

      Oh, Tara, I love to chat, too! Social chat is a part of our group dynamic. We visit while we eat and have a (mostly unspoken)understanding that when the forks are put down, the notebooks and serious discussion are picked up.

      Thanks for stopping by!

  4. Sounds like a great group, I haven’t found a critique group yet but it’s on my to-do list!
    To answer your question on my blog, I’ve tried writing fantasy in the past but I’m not brilliant at world building, but practise makes perfect! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.